Autopilot Retirement Plans Linked to Twice the Savings Gains, Voya Finds
Voya's own analysis of 310,931 workers in 877 plans links automatic saving features to bigger gains, even for people not digitally engaged.
Workers in retirement plans designed to make saving automatic raised their savings rates by an average of 3.33 percentage points, about twice the 1.64-point rise in traditional plans. That is the finding of an analysis of 310,931 participants in 877 plans, published Nov. 16 by Voya Financial’s Behavioral Finance Institute for Innovation. It is Voya’s own study, and it shows a link, not proof of cause.1
The idea behind these plans is to make the helpful choice the one that happens when you do nothing. Two features are central. Automatic enrollment signs workers up for the plan. Automatic escalation raises the share of pay they put in over time.1
Tom Armstrong, who heads the institute, put the idea this way in Voya’s announcement: “People shouldn’t have to think about retirement every day to keep making progress toward it,”1
A quick note on the units: a percentage point is one slice of a paycheck. Going from saving 6% of pay to 7% is a rise of one point. So 3.33 points is a bit more than three of those steps.
How the study worked, and its limits
Voya looked back at records from plans it administered, comparing results by plan design and by whether people used Voya’s digital tools. Insurance Business describes the period as December 2017 to June 2026.2 Voya published the work to mark the institute’s 10th anniversary. The institute launched in 2016.1
The study was not peer-reviewed, and it comes from a company that sells retirement plans. Plans were not randomly assigned, so the results show an association. Voya’s own release says the better outcomes are “linked to” these designs.1
What the numbers suggest
- Defaults went with bigger gains. Savings rates rose 3.33 points in behaviorally designed plans versus 1.64 points in traditional plans without auto-enroll and auto-escalate. Plans using both features rose 3.56 points.1
- The biggest jump went to people who weren’t clicking around. Among participants who were not digitally engaged, savings rates rose 4.09 points in plans with auto-enrollment and escalation, compared with 0.99 points in traditional plans.1 The biggest rise in savings rate belongs to the least involved group, which is roughly what autopilot is for.
- Engaged savers did well, with a market assist. Digitally engaged participants in behaviorally designed plans saved more than 11% of pay on average, and their balances grew 234.4%.1 Insurance Business reports that compares with 201% for engaged participants in traditional plans.2 That growth includes market gains, so it is not a measure of saving habits alone.1
- Bigger automatic steps may not scare people off. Earlier Voya field research from 2023, done with Carnegie Mellon researchers, found employers may be able to set default raises at 2% instead of 1% without significantly reducing participation.4
These are findings about how employers set up plans, not about what individuals do on their own. “What we’ve learned over the past decade is that better outcomes often start with better design,” Dr. Christelle Ngnoumen, the institute’s lead research director, said in the announcement.1
What comes next
Voya says the institute’s next phase will explore how behavioral science, AI-enabled digital experiences and human expertise can work together to make financial guidance more personal and timely.1
Did this make your day? Give it a cheer.
Sources
- New Voya Research Demonstrates Plans Built on Behavioral Insights Doubled Savings-Rate Gains Voya Financial via Business Wire (FinancialContent copy), 2026-11-16
- Retirement plan design outperforms participant effort, data shows Insurance Business, 2026-11
- Voya study: Savings rates rise 3.33 percentage points StockTitan (reposting the Voya release), 2026-11-16
- Fear Not, Auto-Escalation Not Likely to Reduce Participation NAPA (National Association of Plan Advisors), 2023-05
